Not having finished Outies yet, I asked Carlos if he would like to review Outies, JR Pournelle's sequel to Mote in God's Eye and The Gripping Hand. This is the result.
I'm reviewing the paperback edition of Outies by Jennifer Pournelle, published by New Brookland Press, a copy of which I obtained from Amazon. Is it a print-on-demand press? The book is solidly bound and well-printed. There is a slight cutting glitch on the bottom edge, but it's not noticeable in handling the book. The cover art is not unattractive, and it pertains to the subject matter. A small depiction of various hands appears on the binding, and a bitmapped version is used to separate sections within chapters in the book. (If possible, this probably should be changed to a vector graphic version for less fuzziness.)
Outies is a sequel to The Gripping Hand, Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle's unfortunately weak sequel to their classic space opera/first contact novel, The Mote in God's Eye. Because of its status as a science fiction classic, I will assume everyone here has read Mote, or at least its description in Wikipedia. There's not much to say about The Gripping Hand. It brings to light more of the Muslim and Mormon cultures within the Empire, and it shows the Empire of Man coming up with an analog to the birth control pill for Moties, something that in humans was done with Studebaker-era technology.
Outies is an intellectually richer book than either The Gripping Hand or Mote. One of Niven's major talents was to simplify complicated biological or physical ideas and push them to a breaking point. One of, er, JEP's major talents was to simplify political and social ideas in the same way. At the peak of their powers, it made for strongly and forcefully drawn caricatures that hinted at depths below the surface. At other times, well. Mote was written at their joint authorial peak, but it relied on their simplified biological and political models of the universe for its effects.
Jennifer Pournelle reintroduces complexity to the basic setting with Outies, while still being faithful to The Gripping Hand, Mote, King David's Spaceship, and JEP's CoDominium mercenary stories. [*]
Some SPOILERS.
( Read more... )