Would this be an interesting experiment?

[james_davis_nicoll]

Reviews where the reviewer is denied both the title and the author's name (An editor can put them back in later).

Actually, I seem to recall some publication or other does author-blind reviewing but it's easy enough to track down the author if you have the title and a lot of MSes have that at the top.

Comments

[shsilver.livejournal.com]

And my review of issue 2 ( the story I liked was "The Vanishing Life and Films of Emmanual Escobada."

Wiki on Nemonymous

Nemonymous

[weirdmonger.livejournal.com]

NEMONYMOUS is still going strong:
Nemonymous.com (http://www.nemonymous.com)
And "The Vanishing Life and Films of Emmanuel Escobada" remains anonymous.
Thanks for the reference.